“Mount Fuji Looks At Us”

A Sunday evening on the Midosuji Line, heading south to my home in Nagai. I’m standing, listening to Quirks and Quarks on my iPod, gazing into the middle distance (I think I need glasses, finally). The train stops at Showacho and a crowd gets off, prompting a man, who was standing by the opening doors, to walk deliberately (I am aware) behind me. He is in his 60s, wearing unironically old-fahioned glasses, with grey hair slicked back, and he is dressed in a jacket and tie on a Sunday evening (a time when even most men his age dress casually). Pastor? Teacher? I brace myself for the usual Sales Pitch for Jesus and the offer of a pamphlet, which I will decline. He moves into my line of sight and has one of those confiding looks which are comforting when given by a friend but which put me on guard when they’re given by a stranger. Me of little faith. I ‘fail’ to see him – if he wants to talk, he’s going to have to start the transaction.

Eventually, he pounces.

– “Excuse me? Can you help me?” he asks, unfolding a piece of paper. Written on it are two sentences:

We look at Mount Fuji.

Mount Fuji looks at us.

He helpfully reads them out to me (I should add that I’ve turned off the iPod by this time). Then he asks me, very deliberately, “Do you ever say that second sentence in English?”

I am to the point: “No. Never.”

He gives that involuntary hollow laugh that older Japanese people give when they’re embarrassed or perplexed. “But you could say it, couldn’t you?”

– You could say it, but we wouldn’t say it.

– Why not?

– Because it doesn’t make any sense in English. The first sentence is what we say.

– But we say it in Japanese.

– Okay, but we don’t say it in English.

Embarrassed silence. I try giving him the benefit of the doubt. Perhaps he is speaking figuratively, poetically. Perhaps he is using the wrong verb. I try again, offering a face-saving suggestion:

– Do you mean Mt Fuji overlooks us? Because it’s so big? You can say that.

He sighs shortly, impatiently. He obviously has a high opinion of his written English and is not used to being contradicted.

– No! Look! We believe that Mount Fuji looks at us the way we look at it. Because it’s a god. We believe in mountain gods.

– Where I come from, not many people believe that.

– Excuse me, where are you from?

– Canada, I answered, fumbling for my earphones.

He gives me the look that the good cop in a Japanese police drama gives when offering a bowl of noodles to the guy the bad cop is trying to beat a confession out of. Come on, pal – just between you and me.

– But in Canada, you have many mountains. The Rockies look at you? You sometimes say that, don’t you?

– No. We don’t. I’m sorry. (I expect to get a strongly-worded runic parchment from the Druid Anti-Defamation League  of  British Columbia any day now)

– Well. I see. Thank you.

He does not look grateful. Nor does he look like he sees. I put the phones on just in time for the train to pull into Nagai subway. The doors open, and I look back. He is staring stonily at his piece of paper, and I will not be acknowledged. I guess that will show me.

I wonder how many times he went up and down the line that day, trying to find some foreigner to tell him he was right. And why?

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Blogroll, culture, japan, language, Osaka, trains, travel, 大阪, 日本. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to “Mount Fuji Looks At Us”

  1. Kelly says:

    Because Japanese men like to be right? I guess some people who study another language like to think they are the masters of it, and even when the natives tell them differently they don’t want to be told. Does this make you feel like just saying “yes, we say it that way”, and getting him to shut up? I’m sorry you couldn’t ride the train in peace. But I wonder why they think every foreigner speaks english? For all he knew you could have been portugese or something…

    • nagaijin says:

      “Does this make you feel like just saying “yes, we say it that way”, and getting him to shut up?”

      No way, Kelly. It occurred to me that maybe he’s one of those students who pays money to show his teacher how smart he is, not to learn anything. I worried that his poor teacher might have told him the phrase was wrong, and he was travelling up and down the line looking for someone to contradict him/her so he could wring an apology out of her. I wouldn’t do that to anyone, especially since he was so adamant that I agree ith him.

  2. Orchid64 says:

    This is a good tale to talk about ethnocentrism. He simply couldn’t conceptualize that another culture does not frame reality in the same manner as his, and when confronted with the idea, he roundly rejected it. I’d have told him that things without eyes (or the capacity to pick up visual imagery) cannot “look”. Failing that, I’d have said that Western culture isn’t animistic and we don’t believe mountains , trees, rocks, etc. have gods in them.

    Nothing would have worked, most likely.

    • nagaijin says:

      I thought of saying all those things, but just after the fact (isn’t that what they call ‘staircase wit’?). I’d have asked him if you can say,”the table looks at the carpet”. If I really wanted to get him going, I’d have told him that most young Japanese don’t believe in animism anymore either. That would have been fun.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s